1- Institute of Entomology, Agricultural University of Georgia, University Campus at Digomi, David Aghmashenebeli Alley, 13th km, Tbilisi, Georgia
2- Beekeeper and Beekeeping Consultant, 3000 Welsh Avenue, College Station, Texas 77845, USA
3- Institute of Entomology, Agricultural University of Georgia, University Campus at Digomi, David Aghmashenebeli Alley, 13th km, Tbilisi, Georgia & Invertebrate Research Center, Tetritsklebi, Telavi Municipality – 2200, Telavi, Georgia ,g.japoshvili@agruni.edu.ge
2- Beekeeper and Beekeeping Consultant, 3000 Welsh Avenue, College Station, Texas 77845, USA
3- Institute of Entomology, Agricultural University of Georgia, University Campus at Digomi, David Aghmashenebeli Alley, 13th km, Tbilisi, Georgia & Invertebrate Research Center, Tetritsklebi, Telavi Municipality – 2200, Telavi, Georgia ,
Abstract: (224 Views)
The taxonomic status and placement of the Caucasian honey bee (Apis mellifera caucasica Gorbachev, 1916) (Hymenoptera: Apidae) remains puzzling, largely based on outdated investigations. After reviewing available scientific sources, we conclude that initially there was a confusing mismatch between the traditional geographical understanding of the Caucasus and the actual distribution of A. m. caucasica. Insufficient geographic sampling of honeybees across the Caucasus, a statistically inadequate number of studied samples, and incomplete research methodology are major drawbacks of previous studies. Morphometric reference data derived from an extremely limited number of samples still is in use as a standard for the identification of A. m. caucasica. It is highly probable, that this standard does not reflect true morphometric diversity, covering natural geographical variations, which most importantly hinder preservation or breeding efforts. To resolve these deficits, honeybees of the Caucasus and adjacent regions need to be studied in more detail with greater depth of sampling. A thorough study, using modern morphometric approaches and molecular genetic methods, is needed to characterize A. m. caucasica and produce a statistically robust dataset for due reconsideration of its taxonomic status and placement.
Article Type: Research Article |
Subject:
Systematics/Hymenoptera
Received: 2024/09/24 | Accepted: 2025/02/7
Received: 2024/09/24 | Accepted: 2025/02/7
References
1. Alpatov, W.W. (1929) Biometrical studies on variation and races of the honey bee (Apis mellifera L.). The Quarterly Review of Biology, 4 (1), 1-58. [DOI:10.1086/394322]
2. Alpatov, W.W. (1948) The races of honeybees and their use in agriculture. Sredi Prirodi, 4, 1-65.
3. Andguladze, D. & Prangulashvili, V. (1982) Beekeeping. Ganatleba, Tbilisi. 252 p. [in Georgian]
4. Bąk, B., Wilde, J. & Siuda, M. (2010) Comparison of hygienic behaviour between five honey bee breeding lines. Journal of Apicultural Science, 54 (2), 17-24.
5. Bilash, G. & Krivtsov, N. (1991) Selection of Bees. Agropromizdat, Leningrad. 301 p. [in Russian]
6. Bouga, M., Alaux, C., Bienkowska, M., Büchler, R., Carreck, N.L., Cauia, E., Chlebo, R., Dahle, B., Dall'Olio, R., De la Rúa, P., Gregorc, EA., Ivanova, E., Kence, A., Kence, M., Kezic, N., Kiprijanovska, H., Kozmus, P., Kryger, P., Le Conte, Y., Lodesani, M., Murilhas, A.M., Siceanu, A., Soland, G., Uzunov A. & Wilde, J. (2011) A review of methods for discrimination of honey bee populations as applied to European beekeeping. Journal of Apicultural Research, 50 (1), 51-84. [DOI:10.3896/IBRA.1.50.1.06]
7. Butlerow, A. (1880) Beekeeping. The Beekeeper, 2 (1), 1-5.
8. Çakmak, İ., Fuchs, S., Çakmak, S.S., Koca, A.Ö., Nentchev, P. & Kandemir, İ. (2014) Morphometric analysis of honeybees distributed in northern Turkey along the Black Sea coast. Uludağ Arıcılık Dergisi, 14 (2), 59-68. [DOI:10.31467/uluaricilik.376836]
9. De la Rúa, P., Jaffé, R., Dall'Olio, R., Muñoz, I., & Serrano, J. (2009) Biodiversity, conservation and current threats to European honeybees. Apidologie, 40 (3), 263-284. [DOI:10.1051/apido/2009027]
10. Dolgieva, Z.M., Bazgiev, M.A., Dolgiev, M.M., Katsiev, A.S. & Yandiev, A.M. (2021) Effect of bees' welfare on the development and productive qualities of honeybee colonies of various breeds in the Republic of Ingushetia. In IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 624 (1), 012136. [DOI:10.1088/1755-1315/624/1/012136]
11. Engel, M. (1999) The taxonomy of recent and fossil honey bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae; Apis). Journal of Hymenoptera Research, 8, 165-96.
12. Farshineh Adl, M.B., Gençer, H.V., Firatli, Ç. & Bahreini, R. (2007) Morphometric characterization of Iranian (Apis mellifera meda), Central Anatolian (Apis mellifera anatoliaca) and Caucasian (Apis mellifera caucasica) honey bee populations. Journal of Apicultural Research, 46 (4), 225-231. [DOI:10.1080/00218839.2007.11101399]
13. FAO (2015) Food & Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Beekeeping revitalization project takes off in Azerbaijan. Available from: https://www.fao.org/family-farming/detail/en/c/286322/ [Accessed February 3, 2025]
14. GBIF Secretariat (2025) GBIF Backbone Taxonomy. Available from: https://www.gbif.org/species/10903892 [Accessed January 13, 2025]
15. Gorbachev, KA. (1916) Caucasian gray mountain bee (Apis mellifera var. caucasica) and it's place among other bees. Caucasian Silk Station, Tiflis. 42 p. [in Russian]
16. Gruber, K., Schöning, C., Otte, M., Kinuthia, W. & Hasselmann, M. (2013) Distinct subspecies or phenotypic plasticity? Genetic and morphological differentiation of mountain honey bees in East Africa. Ecology and evolution, 3 (10), 3204-3218. [DOI:10.1002/ece3.711]
17. ICZN (1999) International Code of Zoological Nomenclature. Fourth Edition. ITZN, London. i-xxx + 306 p.
18. Japoshvili, G., Kostjukov, V. & Kosheleva, O. (2016) New record of Tamarixia (Hymenoptera: Eulophidae) from Transcaucasia with some taxonomic and biogeographical notes. Journal of the Entomological Research Society, 18 (3), 113-120.
19. Kandemir, İ., Kence, M., & Kence, A. (2005) Morphometric and electrophoretic variation in different honeybee (Apis mellifera L.) populations. Turkish Journal of Veterinary & Animal Sciences, 29 (3), 885-890.
20. Kaskinova, M.D., Gaifullina, L.R. & Saltykova, E.S. (2024) The Genetic Characteristics of the Gray Mountain Caucasian Bee Apis mellifera caucasica. Russian Journal of Genetics, 60 (8), 1134-1138. [DOI:10.1134/S1022795424700613]
21. Khazuev, B.V. & Baimatov, V.L. (1996) Peter Pallas - "Russian German". Bulletin of Russian Academy of Science, 66 (1), 73-77. [in Russian]
22. Koschevnikov, G.A. (1900) Breeds of Caucasian Bees. Russian Beekeeping Society, 15th issue, Saint Petersburg, 24 p. [in Russian]
23. Krikorova, O.V. (2001) Biological and morphological characteristics of purebred and crossbred bees kept in the Republic of Dagestan, and their resistance to disease pathogens. Ph.D Dissertation, Dagestan State Pedagogical University. Makhachkala. 125 p. [in Russian]
24. Krivtsov, N.I., Goryacheva, I.I. & Borodachev, A.V. (2011) Investigation of honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) breeds and populations for developing criteria for genetic certification of bees. Russian Agricultural Sciences, 37, 79-82. [DOI:10.3103/S1068367411010101]
25. Kurtubadze, M. (2016) WWF-Caucasus. GRID-Arendal. Arctic shipping activity in 2015 [Internet]. GRID-Arendal; Available from: https://www.flickr.com/photos/gridarendal/31514191774/in/album-72157679245348155 [Accessed January 3, 20205]
26. Liubimov, M.E. (2010) Selection and reproduction of Caucasian gray bee breeds. PhD. Dissertation, Russian State Agrarian University named after K.A. Timiryazev. Available from: http://www.dissercat.com/content/ selektsiya-i-reproduktsiya-pchel-seroi-gornoi-kavkazskoi-porody [Accessed January 3, 2025] [in Russian]
27. Manel, S., Schwartz, M. K., Luikart, G. & Taberlet, P. (2003) Landscape genetics: combining landscape ecology and population genetics. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 18 (4), 189-197. [DOI:10.1016/S0169-5347(03)00008-9]
28. Meixner, M.D., Costa, C., Kryger, P., Hatjina, F., Bouga, M., Ivanova, E. & Büchler, R. (2010) Conserving diversity and vitality for honey bee breeding. Journal of Apicultural Research, 49 (1), 85-92. [DOI:10.3896/IBRA.1.49.1.12]
29. Meixner, M.D., Büchler, R., Costa, C., Francis, R.M., Hatjina, F., Kryger, P., Uzunov, A., Carreck, N.L. (2014) Honey bee genotypes and the environment. Journal of Apicultural Research, 53 (2), 183-187. [DOI:10.3896/IBRA.1.53.2.01]
30. Meixner, M.D., Büchler, R., Costa, C., Andonov, S., Bienkowska, M., Bouga, M., Filipi, J., Hatjina, F., Ivanova, E., Kezic, N., Kryger, P., Le Conte, Y., Panasiuk, B., Petrov, P., Ruottinen, L., Uzunov, A. & Wilde, J. (2015) Looking for the best bee. An experiment about interactions between origin and environment of honey bee strains in Europe. American Bee Journal, 155 (6), 663-666.
31. Momeni, J., Parejo, P., Nielsen, R.O., Langa, J., Montes, I., Papoutsis, L., Farajzadeh, L., Bendixen, C., Căuia, E., Charrière, J-D., Coffey, M.F., Costa, C., Dall'Olio, R., De la Rúa, P., Drazic, M.M., Filipi, J., Galea, T., Golubovski, M., Gregorc, A., Grigoryan, K., Hatjina, F., Ilyasov, R., Ivanova, E., Janashia, I., Kandemir, I., Karatasou, A., Kekecoglu, M., Kezic, N., Matray, E.S., Mifsud, D., Moosbeckhofer, R., Nikolenko, A.G., Papachristoforou, A., Petrov, P., Pinto, M.A., Poskryakov, A.V., Sharipov, A.Y., Siceanu, A., Soysal, M.I., Uzunov, A., Zammit-Mangion, M., Vingborg, R., Bouga, M., Kryger, P., Meixner, M.D. & Estonba, A. (2021) Authoritative subspecies diagnosis tool for European honey bees based on ancestry informative SNPs. BMC Genomics, 22, 1-12. [DOI:10.1186/s12864-021-07379-7]
32. Mumladze, I. (1971) The comparative study of Georgian bee populations according to morphological characters. Proceedings of Georgian Experimental Station of Bees (Tbilisi: Mecniereba), 2, 49-63. [in Georgian]
33. Pollmann, A. (1889) Werth der verschiedenen Bienenracen und deren Varietäten, bestimmt durch Urtheile namhafter Bienenzüchter. H. Voigt, Leipzig. 112 p. [in German]
34. Pourelmi, M.R. & Fuchs, S. (2017) The south-eastern dıstrıbutıon limit of Apis mellifera, a morphometric study of the honey bees (Apis mellifera L.) of Sistan-Belutschistan. Uludağ Arıcılık Dergisi, 16 (2), 67-75. [DOI:10.31467/uluaricilik.379492]
35. Puškadija, Z., Kovačić, M., Raguž, N., Lukić, B., Prešern, J. & Tofilski, A. (2020) Morphological diversity of Carniolan honey bee (Apis mellifera carnica) in Croatia and Slovenia. Journal of Apicultural Research, 60 (2), 326-336. [DOI:10.1080/00218839.2020.1843847]
36. Randi, E. (2008) Detecting hybridization between wild species and their domesticated relatives. Molecular Ecology, 17 (1), 285-293. [DOI:10.1111/j.1365-294X.2007.03417.x]
37. Requier, F., Garnery, L., Kohl, P.L., Njovu, H.K., Pirk, C.W., Crewe, R.M. & Steffan-Dewenter, I. (2019) The conservation of native honey bees is crucial. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 34 (9), 789-798. [DOI:10.1016/j.tree.2019.04.008]
38. Ruttner, F. (1988) The Races of the Near East (Irano-Ponto-Mediterranean Area). In: Biogeography and Taxonomy of Honeybees. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg, pp. 192-198. [DOI:10.1007/978-3-642-72649-1_11]
39. Sheppard, W.S. (2012) Honey bee genetic diversity and breeding-towards the reintroduction of European germplasm. American Bee Journal, 152, 155-158.
40. Sheppard, W.S. & Meixner, M.D. (2003) Apis mellifera pomonella, a new honey bee subspecies from Central Asia. Apidologie, 34 (4), 367-375. [DOI:10.1051/apido:2003037]
41. Simone-Finstrom, M. & Spivak, M. (2010) Propolis and bee health: the natural history and significance of resin use by honey bees. Apidologie, 41 (3), 295-311. [DOI:10.1051/apido/2010016]
42. Tarkhnishvili, D. (2014) Historical Biogeography of the Caucasus. NOVA Science Publishers, New York. 234 p.
43. Taranov, G.F. (1951) Biological and economic characteristics of the Georgian mountain grey breed. Pchelovodstvo, 1, 15-20. [in Russian]
44. vanEngelsdorp, D. & Meixner, M.D. (2010) A historical review of managed honey bee populations in Europe and the United States and the factors that may affect them. Journal of Invertebrate Pathology, 103 (suppl.), 80-95. [DOI:10.1016/j.jip.2009.06.011]
45. Yıldız, B.İ., Tüten, E., Aydın, S., Aslan, Y.K., Çetin, R., Sur, E. & Karabağ, K. (2023) study of whether the genetic variation decreased or not in the protected Caucasian bee, Apis mellifera caucasica Pollmann, 1889 (Hymenoptera: Apidae) population in isolated regions. Turkish Journal of Entomology, 47 (3), 271-282. [DOI:10.16970/entoted.1273612]
46. Zazanashvili, N., Sanadiradze, G., Bukhnikashvili, A. (1999) Caucasus. In: Mittermeier, R.A., Myers, N., Robles Gil, P. & Mittermeier, C.G. (eds) Hotspots: Earth's Biologically Richest and most Endangered Terrestrial Ecoregion. Conservation International, CEMEX, Agrupación Sierra Madre, Monterrey, Mexico City, pp. 269-273.
47. Zazanashvili, N., Sanadiradze, G., Bukhnikashvili, A., Kandaurov, A., Tarkhnishvili, D. (2004) Caucasus. In: Mittermeier, R.A., Gil, P.R., Hoffmann, M., Pilgrim, J., Brooks, T., Mittermeier, C.G., Lamoreaux, J. & Da Fonseca, G.A.B. (eds) Hotspots Revisited: Earth's Biologically Richest and most Endangered Terrestrial Ecoregion. Conservation International, CEMEX, Agrupación Sierra Madre, Monterrey, pp. 148-152
48. Zazanashvili, N., Manvelyan, K., Askerov, E., Mousavi, M., Krever, V., Kalem, S. & Garforth, M. (2020) The boundaries and bio-physical features of the Caucasus Ecoregion. In Zazanashvili, N., Garforth, M. & Bitsadze, M. (eds) Ecoregional Conservation Plan for the Caucasus, 2020 Edition: Supplementary Reports. WWF, KfW, Tbilisi, pp. 9-20.
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |